I love God. I love my family. I love people (that item's fairly new on the menu). I love the privilege of living in the United States of America, and I have an overwhelming sense of gratitude for the men and women who have died (and lived!) to obtain and defend our freedom.
I want to know your convictions -- not your personal predispositions, but your true convictions as guided by the Holy Spirit -- on this subject (this makes a major assumption that only Christ-followers find any worth in my blog).
Speaking to Americans, what do you find appropriate for a corporate worship service when Independence Day rolls around? Thanking God for the massive, unmerited grace He's shown to the United States as a whole? Thanking Him for the sacrifice of the soldiers, both uniformed and "minutemen," who have, over the centuries, made our cushy lifestyle possible? Conducting a "normal" worship service (which would itself probably be impossible unless many had paid for our freedom with their lives)?
All of those, I believe, are appropriate.
But what I fear about a worship service focused on those things is the possibility, even probability, that America as an entity will be lifted up and put in a higher place than God Almighty. I'm not kidding -- this really frightens me. Where I seem to commit some sort of heresy in conversations with friends is the point at which I say something like, "I really don't know if My Country, 'Tis of Thee is appropriate for a worship service." Here's what I mean:
My country, 'tis of thee,
Sweet land of liberty;
Of thee I sing.
Land where my fathers died,
Land of the pilgrims' pride.
From every mountainside,
Let freedom ring!
That is an awe-inspiring, majestic song! It fills me with pride to say, "Yep, I'm an American, and I honestly don't care whether or not your country loves us OR our president!" But when I meet with the body of Christ to worship, I don't intend to praise or sing about my country. Our purpose is to praise and sing to our God (I should note that the last verse of this hymn does that). Why do I come across as the anti-patriot by saying something like that?
Does anyone see any danger in singing songs like this in a worship service?
(Note: my mom mentioned Our God, Our Help in Ages Past, among a few others, as a great song for this kind of service. I totally concur, although it may be too obscure to garner congregational participation. Be sure to click on the link and read the lyrics.)
Manga, anyone?
-
[image: Serious Post Ahead warning sign]
Not my usual post, thought it needed a warning!
I was in Barnes & Noble the other day, and noticed something that ...
9:02 AM
Posted in: 

7 comments:
Well, God emphasizes praying for Jerusalem and the Psalmsist sings about her (I just read Psalm 122 this morning). I don't think that it's out of place to acknowledge the wonderful, God-given country we live in during our worship service. Those of us there know that without God, America would be nothing. Those who would place America before God, won't be there anyway - I don't think. Does that make sense? The same goes for acknowledging those who have fought for America. Those are my convictions on the matter. I'm always open for God to change my convictions as He sees fit, but as of now that's how I see it. BTW, you say, "But what I fear about a worship service focused on those things is the possibility, even probability, that America as an entity will be lifted up and put in a higher place than God Almighty. I'm not kidding -- this really frightens me". Fear is not of God, but you knew that already.
I wanted to add that I strongly, adamently request that we not sing, "Pledge Allegiance to the Lamb". I know that probably sounds horrific of me, but that song has been done SOOOO MUCH, that to me it is now, well... not as meaningful (that's not what I really wanted to say, but I'm trying to watch my words). OK, you can now stone me if you wish.
Sing praises to the Lord who reigns in Jerusalem.
Tell the world about his unforgettable deeds.
...
Arise, O Lord!
Do not let mere mortals defy you!
Judge the nations!
Make them tremble in fear, O Lord.
Let the nations know they are merely human.
- Psalm 9:11, 19-20
In the context of my post, I believe that fear of the Lord is very appropriate. The fear that you're speaking of is (I'll bet) from 1 John 4:18-19: "Such love has no fear, because perfect love expels all fear. If we are afraid, it is for fear of punishment, and this shows that we have not fully experienced his perfect love. We love each other because he loved us first."
That's speaking to the fear of judgment by God, which the Christ-follower need not have.
Thanks for your candid, honest anti-request. :) I understand completely, and I'll bet you'd be surprised to know that you may actually be in the majority. I should note that someone requested it yesterday, though... :)
Let's do "Oh Canada".
Guess who? :)
I apologize for misuderstanding your type of fear. :) Fear of God - good. Fear of other stuff - not good. We're in agreement, then? Good.
In "The Four Loves", C.S. Lewis quotes Denis de Rougemont saying "love ceases to be a demon only when he ceases to be a god." Patriotism is no exception to this, so your fear isn't completely ungrounded. However, I don't think that playing a patriotic song in church warrants any concern so long as the context of thanks to God is maintained. That said, there are many more songs that I'd rather sing than the popular patriotic tunes.
I'll probably irritate some people by saying so, but I think that people who turn a blind eye to the problems in our country, especially those things which challenge our Christian beliefs, under the guise of patriotism may be crossing into dangerous territory. Should we really be offended when other nations suggest we may be out of line? I wonder how many of us actually consider the accusation before we try to defend the actions of our government. I don't know if anyone who reads this has seen it, but I would be very interested in seeing the "Is America Really Christian?" DVD that Ravi Zacharias International Ministries offers. Sorry for the disjointed rant... one of those days I suppose.
--J.P.
I too vote for "Oh Canada"! - a great song. Who else has listened to Five Iron Frenzy?????? (I've been to 4 of their concerts I believe and can probably sing any of their songs!)
I too think that thanksgiving and seeking and entreating God are appropriate for a worship service that is patriotic in theme. But I think we cross a line when we worship America. I am thankful to live here, but we must never stop seeking God and we must remember that living in a democracy or America is NOT our Savior. Wonderful, yes. We have it good. We should be thankful. But our adoration and worship should only go to God.......
Post a Comment